How to pass the Wharton Team-Based Discussion interview
Congratulations!
You have been invited
to interview with Wharton.
Now what?
Since 2012, I have helped many clients pass their Wharton Team-Based Discussion and One-on-One interviews.
Some worked with me on interviews for one or two hours, others for as many as five hours.
In the process, I gained some insights into the Wharton Team-Based Discussion and One-on-One interviews.
How do I help clients prepare for the Wharton TBD?
First, I listen to their ideas for how to answer the new prompt
I check their assumptions and ask them to define key terms
Through Socratic method, I help them clarify their logic
Then, I listen to how they plan to present their possible answers to the prompt
Through this process, I help them gain confidence that their ideas are likely to make sense to others
I do not provide clients with answers. Rather, I ask them questions, and listen to their answers
Hard work and practice are likely to pay dividends at your Wharton interview
If you want my help preparing for your interview, please complete my prospective client intake questionnaire
I will confirm if I have the capacity to help you
Please note that initial consultations are not offered for interview training
What to prepare before the Zoom call
Send me the information you have received from Wharton regarding your interview.
I promise to keep everything confidential.
Prepare your ideas and possible answers for the Team-Based Discussion and/or One-on-One interview.
Send me your preliminary notes, questions, and ideas
Once I understand how you think and where you are getting stuck, I will do my best to help you during our online session
What I will cover in the call
We will start with the Team-Based Discussion
I want to hear your possible answers to each prompt
If you need help generating ideas, I can help you clarify your logic and ideas
I do not, however, tell you what to say or how to say it
Instead, I pull the ideas out of you through dialogue and discussion
I encourage you to record our session for review and self-study
Finally, if you want to practice for the one-on-one interview, please also send me your resume
How to win the Wharton Team-Based Discussion
I don't think the content of your one-minute answer matters as much as your tone and behavior when collaborating with others
Talk about something you know well
Share an idea that you feel passionately about
But don't take your idea or yourself too seriously - your goal is not to have the group pick your idea
Rather, you goal is to show love for your group and the group discussion process
What matters most to Wharton - you fit their culture and respect their people
Golden rule - not the cynical version, "The one who has all the gold makes the rules"
Rather, the original version - "Treat others as you want to be treated"
Ask yourself,
What does the group need at this moment?
How can I facilitate that need?
You're not trying to be the leader
Nor are you simply trying to be the note taker
I think the situational leadership model fits here
SITUATIONAL LEADERSHIP MODEL
In simple terms, a situational leader is one who can adopt different leadership styles depending on the situation.
• Directing Leaders define the roles and tasks of the 'follower', and supervise them closely. Decisions are made by the leader and announced, so communication is largely one-way.
• Coaching Leaders still define roles and tasks, but seeks ideas and suggestions from the follower. Decisions remain the leader's prerogative, but communication is much more two-way.
• Supporting Leaders pass day-to-day decisions, such as task allocation and processes, to the follower. The leader facilitates and takes part in decisions, but control is with the follower.
• Delegating Leaders are still involved in decisions and problem solving, but control is with the follower. The follower decides when and how the leader will be involved.
DEVELOPMENT LEVEL
Blanchard and Hersey extended their model to include the Development Level of the follower. They said that the leader's style should be driven by the Competence and Commitment of the follower, and came up with four levels:
D4
High Competence High Commitment
Experienced at the job, and comfortable with their own ability to do it well.
D3
High Competence Variable Commitment
Experienced and capable, but may lack the confidence to go it alone, or the motivation to do it well / quickly
D2
Some Competence Low Commitment
May have some relevant skills, but won't be able to do the job without help.
The task or the situation may be new to them.
D1
Low Competence Low Commitment
Generally lacking the specific skills required for the job in hand,
and lacks any confidence and / or motivation to tackle it.
Most of all, show self-awareness and self-control
Keep a sense of humor about your performance when discussing it at the one on one interview
FINAL TIP
Write down the groups and teams with which you work well
Remember the positive and productive discussions that you've had, the business meetings, the conversations where you were able to contribute something and also where others were able to feel comfortable sharing their ideas
I make these videos because I want to pass along some skills to help you live free from negative stereotypes and self-limiting beliefs
Thanks for watching
Please subscribe for the latest updates
And most of all enjoy the process!
Five ways to fail the Wharton Team-Based Discussion
1. LOGIC FAIL
what you say
Problem:
your answers to prompts seem unclear
Cause:
lack of preparation
lack of critical feedback
Effect:
team and evaluators doubt your analytical skills
Solutions:
know your material
chose a key business skill or a societal challenge you could discuss for 45 minutes
take a position that you can support with personal examples
defend your position, while acknowledging good points made by others
solicit constructive criticism of your ideas before the real interview
TBD PROMPT 1
"one key business skill business leaders must have in order to be successful, long-term"
My answer: storytelling
I define storytelling as the ability to convey a message about important information in a way that will engage an audience
Step 1: core problem (business leaders often struggle to communicate important information in a way that will engage stakeholders)
Step 2: immediate cause (why business leaders lack storytelling skills)
Step 3: immediate effect (how lack of storytelling skills might limit long-term career success)
TBD PROMPT 2
"most important societal challenge that could be addressed more effectively by the business community today"
My absolute answer:
Climate change?
My Wharton TBD answer:
Problem: children cannot access the best education
Cause: lack of resources
Effect: inequality, lost opportunity for individuals and society
How business leaders can help: provide resources including time, money, and in-kind donations
Business wins
good will with current client base
grassroots marketing (future customers)
tax breaks?
Society wins
educated citizens
innovative workers
dynamic communities
______________________________
2. TEAMWORK FAIL
how you treat others
Problem:
you appear stubborn, inflexible, argumentative
Cause:
you view teammates as adversaries
they must 'lose' so you can 'win'
Effect:
team and evaluators think you lack interpersonal skills or refuse to acknowledge your errors
Solutions:
change your perceptions
if you are wrong, admit it
if others are wrong, help them by asking questions and introducing facts that help them recognize flaws in their logic
incorporate others' ideas into your own
prepare to have your idea synthesized into a new form
______________________________
3. VOCAL FAIL
how others hear you
Problems:
speed
verbal junk (um, er, ah, well, you know, so)
Cause:
fear of being evaluated negatively
uncomfortable with the material / insufficient preparation
Effect:
team and facilitators evaluate you negatively
Solutions:
slow down
say the complete thought in your head before sharing your idea with the group (sometimes hard if discussion is moving quickly)
______________________________
4. BODY LANGUAGE FAIL
how others perceive you
Problem:
overly passive or overly aggressive body language
Cause:
you feel insecure or threatened
Effect:
you appear threatening
"60 to 70 percent of all meaning is derived from nonverbal behavior"
Solutions:
manage how you appear to others
______________________________
5. PERSPECTIVE FAIL
how you feel about the situation
Problem:
caring too much
Cause:
lack of perspective
Effect:
you appear desperate
Solutions:
list your options if Wharton does not work out
TBD is only one data point for adcom
keep a sense of humor
remember to smile
remember to breathe
One-on-One Interview
The one-on-one component will be 10-15 minutes in length and an opportunity for you to further converse with a member of the Admissions team regarding your candidacy.
While we will have questions for you during this time, we also realize that there are specific aspects that you wish to highlight, such as
your reflections on the Team-Based Discussion,
aspects of your candidacy that you feel are of particular importance, or
updates on your professional or personal endeavors.
This time will also allow for you to ask any questions that you may have regarding the program or next steps in the process.
How to fail your Wharton One-on-One Interview
Please do not fail to close the sale
Insead, use this opportunity to show
a. self-awareness: share surprises and takeaways from Team-Based Discussion (TBD)
b. judgment: share recent professional and personal achievement
c. passion: ask customized questions that engage your interviewer
d. commitment: make sure they know that you will attend if they admit you
Related articles
for reference
WHARTON ADMISSIONS CRITERIA
1. Academic Profile: The grade point average (GPA) is not evaluated without considering other demands on the applicant's time such as working while in school and heavy involvement in extracurricular activities.
2. Work Experience: the Committee looks at the nature of work, the level of challenge, supervision and progression of responsibility. What is more important than the industry ... is what he or she has contributed to his/her work environment and what he/she has learned from successes and failures
3. Personal Qualities: the Committee is looking for people who are self-aware, personally and professionally mature, have a history of being passionately involved in their communities and activities (including work) and will benefit from and contribute to Wharton
4. Overall Presentation: comes partly from a polished, well-organized application and partly from the message an applicant chooses to send by the tone and topics they discuss in their essays, the type of references they choose, etc.
During our session(s), I can help you prepare for all aspects of the interview, which include
Team-Based Discussion (TBD)
Short (10-15) one-on-one conversation regarding your candidacy with a member of the Admissions staff or Admission Fellow, including "reflections on the team-based discussion, aspects of candidacy that the applicant feels are of particular importance, or updates on professional or personal endeavors"
Q&A, where you can ask your interviewer some questions of your own
Sessions are conducted via Skype and/or at my Tokyo office (Japan-based clients may choose either option; clients outside Japan will practice over Skype, preferably using Skype video)
Clients are encouraged to record our mock interview session(s) for later review and ongoing self-study
Please follow the five sign-up steps below if you would like to secure my time
STEP ONE: CONTACT ME AT LEAST 5 DAYS PRIOR TO YOUR ACTUAL INTERVIEW
Please complete my intake form
Let me know when you plan to interview, and when you want to practice with me
I will confirm if I have the capacity to help you
STEP TWO: ARRANGE PAYMENT
My fees are listed here
HOW TO PAY
Clients in Japan pay via bank transfer or cash
Clients outside Japan pay via PayPal
Japan-based clients that want to pay via PayPal are subject to a 5% handling fee to cover PayPal charges
STEP THREE: SCHEDULE YOUR FIRST SESSION TO OCCUR AT LEAST 3 DAYS PRIOR TO YOUR ACTUAL INTERVIEW
I will give you access to my calendar once payment clears
Finally, please follow my cancellation policy
If necessary, requests to reschedule appointments should be made at least 24 hours in advance of the originally scheduled appointment time
Rescheduling requests made less than 24 hours prior to an appointment will be granted at Vince’s discretion
STEP FOUR: SEND ME YOUR RESUME AS WELL AS YOUR IDEAS for the TEAM-BASED DISCUSSION PROMPT
During our session(s), I can help you prepare for all aspects of the interview, which include
Team-Based Discussion
Short (10-15) one-on-one conversation regarding your candidacy with a member of the Admissions staff or Admission Fellow during the interview, including "reflections on the Team-Based Discussion, aspects of candidacy that the applicant feels are of particular importance, or updates on professional or personal endeavors"
Q&A, where you can ask your interviewer some questions of your own
I will prepare a list of questions and situations in advance of our session
I will not provide you with my list of questions and situations in advance of our session because I want to simulate the conditions of your actual interview
I will take notes during our session
After our session, I will send you my question list, as well as the notes I took during our session
I charge a one-hour (60-minute) minimum for Wharton interview training
Clients may also purchase additional time in 60-minute (one hour) blocks
That addional time may be used to practice for the Team-Based Discussion and/or one-on-one conversation and final Q&A session
It may also be used to discuss interview techniques and strategy, debrief after the interview, draft a follow-up thank you note, disucss waitlist strategies, or plan for reapplication (as needed)
After our initial practice, I will provide my professional opinion about how much follow time might be needed, if any
I can also refer interview candidates to other counselor in my network for a second or third opinon
Please note, each counselor in my network has his or her own way of preparing clients for the new Wharton interview process
Skype-based training can be conducted in one of two ways
A one-hour (60 minute session), or
A series of two 30-minute sessions (2 sessions x 30 minutes = 60 minutes total)
In the first of our two 30 minute sessions, we can focus on the Team-Based Discussion
I will select one of the Team-Based Discussion topics from the list you receive from Wharton (and share with me)
I cannot simulate a true 5-6 person discussion, but I would ask you to share your ideas about the topic I chose
Then, I would engage you in a dialogue regarding the topic to see if we can reach a reasonable conclusion as a two-person team
I will assess both the logic of your content and style of your delivery
I will be checking to see if you able to defend your ideas without sounding defensive
I will also be checking to see if you can confirm the logic of my counter-arguments without completely giving up your own perspective
In the second 30 minute session, I would spend 10-15 15 minutes engaging you in a short one-on-one conversation regarding your candidacy, including "reflections on the Team-Based Discussion, aspects of candidacy that the applicant feels are of particular importance, or updates on professional or personal endeavors"
I would also simulate the final Q&A, where you can ask your interviewer (me) some questions of your own
Since I am not a Wharton graduate, I will not attempt to answer your questions
Rather, I will assess if your questions present you in a positive light and seem likely to engage your interviewer in constructive dialogue
In our final 10-15 minutes, I will provide verbal feedback, consisting of constrictive criticism and suggestions for ways to improve what you say and/or how you say it
Face-to-face interview training would last the full 60 minutes
I charge a 60 minute minimum to meet you in person, since I might need to travel to my office just for our session
Face-to-face interview training would cover everything listed above in the two 30-minute Skype-based sessions
If you want to ask me follow-up questions after the session, I can arrange short (10-15 minute) Skype-based discussions where I answer any questions you send me via email
I would charge you for that service since it would exceed the scope of our 60-minute (or 2x30 minute) mock interview training, outlined above
I do not want to engage interview-training clients in lengthly email or document-based exchanges since the point of interview training is to SPEAK rather than WRITE
Finally, after your interview, I will destroy all hard and soft resume copies to maintain client confidentiality
STEP FIVE: PRACTICE BEFORE and AFTER EACH SESSION
Interviewing is a learned skill
You will improve with practice
Please practice at least three hours before and after each of our mock interview sessions
I encourage you to use my "mirror method" to practice interviews at home
You might also want to read Victor Cheng's excellent "Case Interview Secrets" book
Wharton's Team-Dased Discussion is not likely to be as challenging as a consulting case interview
Still, Victor's book is full of tips and strategies that can help you improve your presenation and discussion skills
Highly recommended for every MBA applicant (and admitted MBA student, even if you are planning to enter the consulting field)
HOW TO CONTACT VINCE
If you want my help preparing for your interview, please complete my prospective client intake questionnaire
I will confirm if I have the capacity to help you
Please note that initial consultations are not offered for interview training
LOGISTICS
For clients outside Tokyo, I provide interview training via phone, Skype, or Google Talk
If you do not have access to those services, I can provide my office phone number, as well as a US phone number that will connect to my Skype account
CANCELLATIONS
If necessary, requests to reschedule appointments should be made at least 24 hours in advance of the originally scheduled appointment time
Rescheduling requests made less than 24 hours prior to an appointment will be granted at Vince’s discretion
As needed, a client may change a face-to-face session to a “distance” session to be conducted over phone or Skype. Please kindly inform Vince ahead of time
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Time purchased from Vince is valid for 12 months from the date of purchase
If you are not 100% satisfied after two weeks of Vince receiving payment, Vince will refund all the unused time, minus any fees incurred in receiving payment (i.e. PayPal charges)
This money-back guarantee does not apply if a client's deadlines fall within the initial two-week period after payment is received
CONFIDENTIALITY
Strict confidentiality is guaranteed
No client information will be shared with other applicants
